Seals do not wear out in the sense that a bearing wears out. They relax. An elastomer held under compression loses some of its ability to spring back, and the compression set that results is the difference between the seal the design intended and the seal the product has after a year.
What compression set measures
Compression set is the permanent deformation left after a specimen is compressed for a stated time at a stated temperature and then released. It is expressed as a percentage of the original deflection: a 25 % compression that springs back to 18 % has a set of about 28 %.
| Elastomer | Set after 24 h at 70 °C | Set after 24 h at 100 °C | Practical IP life |
| Silicone | 10 to 20 % | 20 to 30 % | 10+ years at moderate temperature |
| EPDM | 15 to 25 % | 30 to 40 % | 5 to 10 years outdoors |
| Nitrile | 20 to 30 % | 35 to 50 % | 3 to 5 years with oil contact |
| Neoprene | 25 to 35 % | 40 to 55 % | 3 to 6 years |
Why the IP test does not see it
The type test is run on a new sample. Compression set is a slow process that needs months at service temperature, and no routine ingress test runs long enough to reveal it. A product can therefore hold its rating in the certificate and lose it in the field.
What to do about it
- Specify compression set, not just hardness, on the gasket drawing. A 25 % set limit at 70 °C for 24 h is a reasonable target for most enclosures.
- Design for 20 to 30 % deflection when new. Under 15 % and the seal is not loaded enough; over 40 % and set accelerates.
- Run an accelerated ageing test: 168 h at 20 K above the maximum service temperature, then repeat the IP test.
- Keep grease compatible with the elastomer; the wrong grease swells the seal and the wrong solvent shrinks it.
Standards referenced: ISO 815-1 for compression set of vulcanised rubber, IEC 60529 for the IP test methods, IEC 60068-2-2 for dry heat ageing.
How to test for it in a week rather than a year
Compression set testing per ISO 815-1 uses a jig that holds the specimen at a fixed deflection, typically 25 %, in an oven at 70 °C for 24 h. The specimen is then released, allowed to recover for 30 minutes, and measured.
The result is expressed as a percentage of the original deflection. A 25 % compression that recovers to 20 % has a set of 20 %. Anything above 30 % for an enclosure gasket is a warning sign.
For a whole-enclosure test, the equivalent is an accelerated ageing run: 168 h at 20 K above the maximum service temperature, then repeat the IP test. A rating that survives this has a realistic claim on a multi-year life.
The groove geometry that decides set
A gasket in a groove that is too shallow is over-compressed and takes a permanent set quickly. One in a groove that is too deep is under-compressed and never seals properly in the first place.
For a 3 mm cord, a groove depth that gives 25 % compression is 2.25 mm. Cut the groove to 2.35 mm and the compression drops to 22 %, which is fine; cut it to 2.0 mm and compression rises to 33 %, which is not.
The repair that is not a repair
Adding grease to a leaking gasket restores the seal temporarily and accelerates set in the long run, because many greases swell or soften the elastomer. If a gasket has taken a permanent set, replace it; do not pack it.
